ByGB Blog Official 2018-11-26 7625
We've already talked about the FIMI A3, Xiaomi’s latest drone, in a dedicated review post. After that, many readers asked if we can make a comparison between Xiaomi FIMI A3 and DJI Spark. So that’s the main topic we are talking about today. Now, we will explore the differences and similarities between the two quadcopters in full.
FIMI A3 5.8G 1KM FPV with 2-axis Gimbal RC Drone from Xiaomi Youpin - WHITE
DJI Spark Mini RC Selfie Drone - WHITE RTF ( CN PLUG, WITH TRANSMITTER ADAPTER )
First, let’s compare the specs of the Xiaomi FIMI A3 and DJI Spark side by side.
|Product name||Xiaomi FIMI A3 RC drone||DJI Spark Mini RC drone|
|Product weight||0.5600 kg||0.3000 kg|
|Product size (L x W x H)||28.50 x 22.90 x 6.90 cm / 11.22 x 9.02 x 2.72 inches||14.30 x 14.30 x 5.50 cm / 5.63 x 5.63 x 2.17 inches|
|Functions||Aerial photography,camera, |
/backward ,FPV,G-sensor mode,
GPS altitude hold,headless mode,one key automatic return,
one key follow,turn left/right,
hgesture mode,headless mode,One |
key automatic return,sense and avoid,sport mode,tap to fly,turn left/right,up/down,visual tracking,WiFi connection
|Satellite system|| |
|Flight modes||Follow me, orbit, fixed wing mode, dronie, headless, one key return||Circle, dronie, rocket, helix, tap to fly|
|Max flying height||500m||4,000m|
|Max speed||65 kph||50 kph|
|Remote control|| |
2.4GHz wireless remote control
|Remote controller screen||Yes||No|
|Detailed control distance||1km||1 - 2km|
|Battery||2950 mAh LiPo battery||1480mAh LiPo battery|
|Gimbal||Controlled rotation scope: 0 - 90 degrees pitch angle |
stabilization: 2-aixs mechanical and 3-aixs electronical gimbal
|Controllable range: pitch: -85 to 0 degree |
stabilization: 2-axis mechanical ( pitch, roll )
|Camera||Sensor: 8MP 1/3.2" (CMOS) |
Lens: FOV 80-degree
ISO range: 100 - 3200 for video, 100 - 1600 for picture
Shutter speed: 4 - 1/8000s
Max video bitrate: 60Mbps
Max photo resolution: 8M 3264 x 2448
Video resolution: 1920 x 1080 30fps / 1920 x 1080 25fps
|Sensor: 12 MP 1/2.3″ (CMOS) |
Lens: FOV 81.9-degree
ISO range: video: 100 - 3200;
photo: 100 - 1600 shutter speed:
2 - 1/8000s
Max video bitrate: 24Mbps
Video resolution: FHD: 1920 x 1080 30fps
|Storage||microSD card||microSD card|
|Price||$258.99 (limited Black Friday sale price)||$778.92|
At the very first look, the two drones do have quite a bit in common. They are both rectangular in shape, come with four propellers and have their cams located at the front. On the bottom, there are the batteries, ports and some basic controls.
There is one very important difference, however. The DJI Spark measures 5.63 x 5.63 x 2.17 inches and weighs just about 300 grams. The FIMI A3, on the other hand, is significantly larger measuring 11.22 x 9.02 x 2.72 inches and weighs most double - 560 grams. Thus, with the FIMI A3, you have a much larger gadget - and this can be both a good and a bad thing. Having a compact drone like the Spark definitely makes it easier to move around and shoot while traveling. On the other hand, when it comes to piloting, a bigger quadcopter like the Xiaomi FIMI A3 may prove to be easier and give you more "feedback" as you are steering. The DJI Spark is sold as a "selfie drone" and we’d say that it’s perfectly sized for moving around. The FIMI A3, on the other hand, will take quite a bit more space and packing skills if you plan to bring it along on a trip.
Since both drones are marketed as entry level devices into aerial photography, it really does matter what kind of cameras they come with. Unfortunately (but quite understandable for the price), neither drone comes with 4K resolution. Instead, you get Full HD cameras on both the Xiaomi FIMI A3 and the DJI Spark capable of recording HD footage at 30 frames per second. The FIMI A3, however, features an 8MP sensor while the Spark sports a better 12MP one. Hence, you get a slightly higher image resolution with the Spark (3968×2976) compared to the FIMI A3 (3264 x 2448).
Stabilization is definitely not something to underestimate on a moving gadget - and you get 2-axis gimbals on both drones to make sure your footage is not shaky. The gimbals will keep your quadcopter’s camera steady throughout the flight, which will ensure smoother videos.
There are quite a few things that might fit under the performance category. When it comes to photo drones, however, we believe that these mainly include battery life, controller and smart flight features.
The DJI Spark comes with a 1480mAh 11.4V LiPo battery, which translates into about 16 minutes of flight time. The FIMI A3 comes with a significantly bigger battery (keep in mind that this is also a much larger quadcopter) – you get a 2950mAh battery onboard that, according to Xiaomi, will give the mini craft 25 minutes in the air. So, technically, you get quite a bit more time in the air with the A3 — but you will be piloting a larger and heavier craft.
The good news is that both quadcopters come with dedicated controllers - this is especially good for pilots who are just starting out as you get plenty of real estate to learn steering the drone instead of just having an app to work with.
There is a difference, however. With the FIMI A3, the physical controller is the only one you have - and you can get started with flying right away. The DJI Spark comes with both the controller and the app - and you can choose how you want to control the drone. Note that there will be some setup work involved and you will need to use your smartphone screen if you want FPV. The FIMI A3, by contrast, uses a controller with a built-in 4.3 inch screen — so, you will be able to see what your quadcopter "is seeing" right on the controller.
Both drones are well equipped for first time fliers. The Xiaomi FIMI A3 comes with the following flight modes: Orbit, Dronie, Fixed Wing Mode and Headless. The Spark features Circle, Dronie, Rocket, Helix and Tap to Fly. These are very helpful when you are just starting out in aerial photography and make both quadcopters popular recommendations for first time flyers.
There are a few differences here as well. The DJI Spark comes with obstacle avoidance feature, which let's the drone automatically avoid bumping into tree tops, roofs, houses, etc. There is also gesture control, which allows the pilot to send several commands to the quadcopter by using hand movements. Unfortunately, the FIMI A3 lacks both of these.
With that, we have to give the Xiaomi FIMI A3 points for creativity. It comes with a special DIY port that lets you hook up external equipment: LED lights, fireworks controller, servo, etc.
Both the DJI Spark and the FIMI A3 are marketed as entry level photography drones. This means that both of them are well equipped for your first steps in aerial photography and are also not as expensive as professional quadcopters.
If you are looking for an entry level drone, both quadcopters are a good fit. However, the FIMI A3 is significantly cheaper than its counterpart. True, it is larger and quite a bit heavier - but, then again, it comes with a simpler setup and more straightforward control system. Thus, if you are looking for a beginner's quadcopter, we'd say that the FIMI A3 is a more budget friendly version that does not lag too much behind its pricier option.
|You may also want to read:|
|Xiaomi FIMI A3 RC drone review: the best drone to get you started in aerial photography|
|Xiaomi MITU mini RC drone review|
|ThiEYE Dr.X WiFi FPV RC drone review|